Why Most Carrier Distribution Strategies Fail
Carrier distribution strategies rarely fail because of a lack of ambition. They fail because of misalignment.
On paper, the strategy looks sound. Expand reach. Recruit more agencies. Add products. Incent compensation. Launch training. Track activity. Yet year after year, many carriers are disappointed by flat growth, inconsistent production, and disengaged field partners.
The root issue is that most distribution strategies are built from the carrier’s perspective rather than the distributor’s reality.
Carriers often design strategies around what they want sold, how fast they want it sold, and which metrics they want reported. Distributors, however, are driven by very different forces. They care about simplicity, predictability, trust, and relevance to their clients. When those priorities are ignored, even well funded initiatives stall.
Another common failure point is confusing scale with strength. Adding more distribution does not automatically create more production. In many cases, it dilutes focus, overwhelms internal teams, and creates noise instead of momentum. Strong distribution is not about how many relationships you have. It is about how deep, aligned, and supported those relationships are.
Execution also breaks down when carriers underestimate the importance of leadership in the field. Growth does not happen through spreadsheets and product decks alone. It happens through confident leaders who understand the carrier’s story, believe in it, and can translate it into action for advisors. Without intentional investment in field leadership development, strategies remain theoretical.
Finally, many strategies fail because they are static in a dynamic market. Distribution partners evolve. Advisor demographics change. Client expectations shift. A strategy that is not revisited, refined, and stress tested against real world feedback quickly becomes outdated.
Winning distribution strategies start with empathy. They are built with the field, not for the field. They prioritize clarity over complexity, depth over breadth, and partnership over pressure. When carriers get those fundamentals right, distribution stops being a problem to manage and starts becoming a competitive advantage.
bigridgeconsulting.com